Well, in the end I think I'm going to go with The Unpleasant Surprise.

At first I didn't like the setup with the switches but I really got into it the second and third time I tried.
Wow, this thing is crazy and versatile!
From a mean octave up to synthy sitar type sounds, sizzling I don't know what the hell is happening type sounds and it even has a nice overdrive.
The thing sounds great running after my distortion as well.
I really want a nasty fuzz right now to complement my rig and this does it, in my opinion it's way more nasty than the LAL stuff.
The TAFM is nice but sounded a bit bland in band context, I mean in the end it just sounds like a good regular fuzz, not something I'll use that much I guess (I'm a bit crazy that way).
The special sounds like the gated stuff and the faux octave up don't really come out in the band much the way I heard it.
Still it's a great pedal though.

The Terra is great, also very versatile, I think maybe in the end I like it even more than the TAFM, I mean it does horn type sounds with the bias below halfway, sounds great when boosted with a distortion in front and can do a proper riffage fuzz as well.
Most of those horn type fuzzes are quite harsh sounding or don't have the feel / gain range for proper riffing but this one does, pretty cool.

This one will stay in the back of my mind, I might get one later on.
The Caracol is also cool, very special.
Mostly I think of it as a banjo generator, it has such a special attack that it really mimics that type of sound.
It can do some flutey stuff too with the control knob completely down and the intensity knob backed off a little.
It's also the only low gain octave up pedal I tried where the octave actually really is able to cut through another fuzz or distortion and get nasty enough, nice.

The only downside with it for me is not being able to control the attack / decay / sustain more, I mean that banjo style thing is great but I would love to be able to have a softer attack and/or a bit longer decay / sustain on it too for more sitar type sounds and it doesn't really seem to do that.
This one is also still in the back of my mind.
good deals with: the_brow, phantasmagorovich, alexsga, DarkAxel, goroth, The Wood Wizard, Tendollarcat, vbps, monkeydancer, intothegroove, Brobee