Page 5 of 15

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Mon Sep 03, 2018 11:01 am
by Dandolin
:)

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Mon Sep 03, 2018 12:40 pm
by oldangelmidnight
Broken switches are annoying. I really don't like regular pots for selecting discrete options, though. Would you be able to make the LED flash or change colors when moving from one program to the next?

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Mon Sep 03, 2018 1:59 pm
by Pladask
oldangelmidnight wrote:Broken switches are annoying. I really don't like regular pots for selecting discrete options, though. Would you be able to make the LED flash or change colors when moving from one program to the next?

A visual aid to replace the lack of tactile response would probably be helpful yes. The numbers would obviously stay whatever I decide to do.

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Mon Sep 03, 2018 8:13 pm
by Heraclitus Akimbo
Pladask wrote:I need your opinion on something. I've had feedback about broken rotary switches from two FABRIKAT owners and I'm now feeling fearful about unleashing large quantities of pedals into the world with rotary switches that may eventually break down (repair work, administering shipments and customs documentation, inconvenience for you the buyer). Generally I despise mechanical components as they are prone to break, hence why I use momentary footswitches for my pedals. So because of this I'm considering to swap the rotary switch for a regular, step-lesss potentiometer that decides the program.


I had a rotary switch on a different pedal go bad on me recently, so I'm down with anything more durable. With that one, I was certainly used to the tactile "click" while changing patches... without that there really ought to be some kind of additional visual feedback. (even better for playing gigs in especially dark places.) Having an LED blink to a different colour or something would be good to know you've switched.

Accidentally changing to a different patch isn't such a big deal for the stuff that I tend to do.

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 12:36 am
by damnableman
xo

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 5:00 am
by Pladask
thanks for the feedback. How do you feel about the selector on the Source Audio Nemesis / Strymon Big Sky? I taking another look at rotary encoders + LEDs.

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 8:40 am
by oldangelmidnight
I haven't used the Nemesis or Big Sky but I like the idea of separate LEDs for the separate programs.

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 10:54 am
by whoismarykelly
Did the users just report breakage for no reason or did they accidentally break the switch while stepping on the pedal? Fabrikat's rotary switch feels very durable to me and I like the distinct feel of moving through the programs. Especially if Im on one program and I need to change another mid set, I can feel the number of clicks I need. That goes away with an encoder/pot.

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 4:44 pm
by Pladask
whoismarykelly wrote:Did the users just report breakage for no reason or did they accidentally break the switch while stepping on the pedal? Fabrikat's rotary switch feels very durable to me and I like the distinct feel of moving through the programs. Especially if Im on one program and I need to change another mid set, I can feel the number of clicks I need. That goes away with an encoder/pot.

Some have broken during installation (by me and workshop goers, I use the same switches in FORM2) and some have been reported broken by users. Got a rough prototype of the Nemesis/BlueSky system up and running today and it seems quite promising. Now I need to order some PCBs and encoders. The encoder I'm currently looking at has 12 distinct steps (detents) per 360 degree. Using an encoder would retain the tactile rotary switch feel. If it works I'll be able to rotate directly from program 8 to 1 (clockwise). Pedal will remember the last selected program on startup and indicate it by illuminating the corresponding LED. Also helps that the encoder seems very sturdy (metal shaft) and comes from a reputable manufacturer. work work...

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 6:27 pm
by damnableman
xo

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 7:24 pm
by whoismarykelly
Pladask wrote:
whoismarykelly wrote:Did the users just report breakage for no reason or did they accidentally break the switch while stepping on the pedal? Fabrikat's rotary switch feels very durable to me and I like the distinct feel of moving through the programs. Especially if Im on one program and I need to change another mid set, I can feel the number of clicks I need. That goes away with an encoder/pot.

Some have broken during installation (by me and workshop goers, I use the same switches in FORM2) and some have been reported broken by users. Got a rough prototype of the Nemesis/BlueSky system up and running today and it seems quite promising. Now I need to order some PCBs and encoders. The encoder I'm currently looking at has 12 distinct steps (detents) per 360 degree. Using an encoder would retain the tactile rotary switch feel. If it works I'll be able to rotate directly from program 8 to 1 (clockwise). Pedal will remember the last selected program on startup and indicate it by illuminating the corresponding LED. Also helps that the encoder seems very sturdy (metal shaft) and comes from a reputable manufacturer. work work...


That sounds legit. The Hexe ReVolver has a similar setup with LEDs corresponding to a program and that works well.

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 8:05 pm
by Teej212
I may be alone in this boat, but I prefer rotary encoders to pots in some cases, this sounds like a clear candidate for an encoder.

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Sat Sep 08, 2018 7:10 pm
by caljoephua
I use a Nemesis and i have to say, the encoder is a big up vote from me! It's brilliant and lovely to use, from a user's standpoint :D

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Fri Sep 21, 2018 5:15 pm
by publicfig
+1 to rotary encoder.

Re: FABRIKAT - Granular Synthesis / Sample Playback

PostPosted: Sat Sep 22, 2018 1:09 am
by Dandolin
:snax: