Hmmm shit tons to consider. Guess I'll just have to try as many of these options as I can eventually.
I really do like the idea of using a heavy distortion with a full range EQ like the Throat Locust as a "fuzz" though. I can't remember if the first distortion I used was an HM-2 or Turbo Rat, but I really loved them both. Going back to an HM-2 but with more everything definitely couldn't hurt.
I definitely know a few people who use the Feed Me as well, but as much as I like the Pelitaur I've just got an itch to try new things and experiment until I find something that is just right. Also I'm clumsy as all hell and don't want to have to step on two switches when I could just do one.
I'll also definitely get a sonic shroom someday... or maybe even a sonic shroom. I just can't resist anything with a second switch to mangle the signal. Also the art on it (and really every current fuzzhugger pedal) is incredible.